I often see clients who are perfectly capable of dealing with problems and still live in fear of finding themselves incapable. I wonder what they imagine will happen if they get something wrong. How long will the other person be angry? What will they do if they can’t explain themselves? Will they know what to do if an apology makes no difference?

I know something about this from my own life. I used to want things to be perfect. If I got one thing exactly right, I could almost believe that everything in my life was right as well. It wasn’t. For a little while, though, I could take the one thing I’d got right as evidence about the rest. I understand why I wanted that feeling. I also understand why it never lasted.

I don’t want to be perfect. I doubt many of us would choose a life that demanded it. But the fear of what might happen if we aren’t can be bigger than the wish to get things right.

Think of an email you’ve already checked. You’re at the end of the day and there’s somebody you like in the next room. You could go and sit with them. Instead, you change the first line so the person receiving it has one less reason to misunderstand you. You try to imagine their face when they read it. You may be at the desk a while. A face you’re imagining can always look a little more displeased.

The short answer

Perfectionism can become a way of heading off a moment when you might feel incapable. If a mistake seems likely to expose something bad about you, or leave you with a problem you don’t believe you can handle, another check makes sense. An old memory can add force to that fear. The question I’d start with is what you believe you could do if something did go wrong.

What if I can’t deal with what happens next?

When somebody says they hate making mistakes, I want to know which part they hate. A wrong figure on a page takes a minute to change. The meeting where it gets pointed out might take them a week to get over. There’s the moment they go blank and can’t think how to answer. There’s the journey home, when they think of six answers they could have given.

That’s where I would look at self-esteem. You may know you’re capable when you can prepare, control the details and go over the answer before anyone sees it. How much faith do you have in yourself when the outcome is in someone else’s hands? Could you hear someone’s disappointment and still have some regard for yourself?

I think you can take enormous pride in your work and have very little confidence in your ability to be seen making a mistake. The two can live side by side for years. I’d also want to know what actually happens in your office when people get things wrong. Some workplaces give you very good reasons to be careful.

How much of your preparation goes into the work, and how much goes into making sure you’ll never have to find out how you cope?

Unrelenting standards and the moving finish line

Unrelenting standards are the demands you keep placing on yourself when your circumstances change, when you’re exhausted or when the work has already done what it needed to do. I like the word unrelenting. It catches the feeling of asking for a bit of room and finding that the answer is always the same. The trap is that the rule can ask the most of you on the days you have the least to give.

Researchers Roz Shafran, Zafra Cooper and Christopher Fairburn describe a pattern in which meeting demanding standards becomes central to how you judge yourself, even as the costs build. The standard can rise after you meet it. Think about the last time you did something well. How long were you pleased? When did you start thinking about what doing well had now made people expect of you? Read the original clinical model.

You can put off a five-minute task for a week if starting it means you’ll eventually have to let someone see how you did. I’d be curious about the moment before you put it off. What do you think you’d be exposing yourself to if you simply sent it?

When an old memory seems to know what will happen

At a meeting table, a large slide viewer shows a pale image of an earlier presentation.

Sometimes the past comes to mind in a very particular way. A colleague says your name before asking a question and you remember someone saying it like that just before laughing at your answer. You didn’t sit down to think about the old incident. A small piece of it arrived while you were doing something else. That’s what I mean here by an intrusive memory.

The replay afterwards is slightly different. You can spend the rest of the meeting thinking through why you froze years ago, or planning how you’ll make certain it never happens again. There can be a memory, a long examination of it, and a prediction about the future, all while the meeting carries on around you.

In a small interview study of 22 people with social anxiety, Ann Hackmann, David Clark and Freda McManus found that many recurrent self-images were linked to earlier painful social experiences. The study looked at social anxiety. It gives us a reason to take the link between memory and the fear of being judged seriously. Whether a memory is helping to keep your perfectionism going needs a closer look at what happens to you now. Read the original interview study.

I’d listen for the conclusion that travels with the memory. Perhaps you remember giving a wrong answer, and what comes with it is the belief that once people see you hesitate, you can never get their respect back. Think of a time someone you respected hesitated. What happened to your respect for them?

When everyone else makes it look easy

An AI can produce a neat reply to the email you’ve avoided for three days. You see the polished answer appear and wonder why a human being with a job, a home and several decades of practice still finds opening the email so hard. The reply may be useful. It can’t tell you why you froze when you saw who it was from, or what it will cost you to say what you actually think.

Or your partner rings the plumber, finds the invoice and books a time while you’re still working out where to start. You may be grateful. You may also feel about six years old. If they say it only took a minute, they’re probably telling you how long it took them. It can sound, from where you’re standing, like the time it ought to have taken you.

I have ADHD, and I recognise autistic traits in myself. I know the feeling of something ordinary taking more out of you than the person next to you could see. There can be a gulf between knowing how a task is done and being able to get started, especially if there are several steps to keep in mind or you’re already tired. And then there’s the embarrassment of having to explain why you needed help with the thing everybody insists is simple. Read NICE guidance on ADHD and day-to-day support.

I’m interested in what happens when we make room for that difference without making you smaller. Perhaps you need the first step written down. Perhaps you and your partner can work out what each of you finds easier. You might say, I’m glad you took care of it. When you say it was easy, I start to feel stupid for finding it hard. Can we talk about what would actually help me next time?

What happens when you bring the rules home?

Two people reach around a giant cobalt magnifying glass that enlarges a striped mug in a kitchen rack.

One person puts the mugs away. The other reaches past them and moves two. Imagine how quickly that can happen. You might only realise you’ve done it when the person beside you goes quiet. They saw your hand move towards the cupboard and understood it as a comment on their effort. You thought you were finishing a small job.

I’d want to know who usually notices the work and who usually finishes it. Sometimes a mug really is the last straw after a week of doing more than you agreed. Sometimes the other person has done their share, and you’re so used to the relief of putting things in order that you straighten what they’ve just done. Your partner still has a right to tell you how that feels. Read more about resentment and shared responsibilities.

There’s a quieter way the rules come home, too. You give the edited version of your day. You tell your partner what you decided and what you’re going to do about it. They hear how you handled it. They may never hear that you had no idea what to do for a while, and that it was lonely. It takes a different kind of confidence to ask someone to sit with you while you’re still working that out.

Give yourself a chance to handle an ordinary mistake

A person leaves an oversized orange winding key behind and walks towards someone offering a cup of tea.

Think of a small plan you need to make with a friend. Decide what the message actually needs: a time, a place and a tone you’d recognise as your own. Read it once for those things. Before you send it, finish this sentence: If they take it the wrong way, I could…

Say your friend replies, Are you annoyed? You might say, No, I was in a rush. I’m looking forward to seeing you. There it is: the misunderstanding you’ve spent half an hour trying to prevent, repaired in a line. If they reply with a thumbs-up and nothing more, give them the benefit of being someone who sometimes replies with a thumbs-up.

A small randomised trial of cognitive behavioural therapy for clinical perfectionism used behavioural experiments to test assumptions about performance. The experiment here is a way of gathering your own evidence in an ordinary situation. A casual message is a good place to start. Keep all the checks your professional responsibilities, safety and other people’s privacy require. Read the preliminary trial.

Afterwards, ask what happened and what you were able to do about it. If you got ten minutes back, you might spend them with the person in the next room. If stopping brings up guilt, read this piece on rest.

When the memory needs its own attention

Some memories come with a sense that the event is happening again. If this happens repeatedly, if sleep is suffering or you’re avoiding places or situations because of the memories, it’s worth talking to your GP or a clinician trained in assessing trauma symptoms. NICE recommends looking at the experience and the wider pattern of symptoms and their effect on daily life. An unwanted memory on its own tells you very little about whether someone has PTSD. You can ask for an assessment without having to settle that question first. Read the NICE guidance on assessment.

There’s something I want to say as a therapist. I care about what happens to the people I sit with. I read and think about this work every day because I want to understand more and have more to offer when someone is stuck. There’s a limit to what I can show you of that from a page. You’d probably know more about how I work from seeing what I do in the room when neither of us knows quite what to say next.

I might ask a question you’d rather I didn’t ask. I might ask whose voice you hear when you call yourself incapable. If my question comes too soon, or I’ve got hold of the wrong end of what you’re telling me, I want you to be able to say so. I can be many things in the room. Perfect isn’t one of them.

I want you to have some hope. If someone tells you there’s a light at the end of the tunnel when you can’t see two feet in front of you, you may feel even more alone. I’d rather start with the thing you can see. There’s a message you haven’t answered. There’s someone in the next room. Maybe the first thing you say to them is, I don’t know why this is so hard for me today. Will you come and sit here for a minute? You don’t have to have an explanation ready for that.

Questions worth sitting with

  • Which mistake would you be most afraid of someone seeing you make? What do you imagine they would do afterwards?
  • Who has seen you at a loss and stayed in the conversation with you?
  • What would you be able to say to someone this week if you could say it before you had a solution?

Frequently asked questions

Can low self-esteem and perfectionism go together?

Yes. If your view of yourself depends heavily on doing things well, a small mistake can carry a lot of weight. You can have confidence in particular abilities and still feel unsure of your worth or your ability to cope when things go wrong.

Is perfectionism the same as OCD?

Perfectionism describes a pattern of standards and self-evaluation. OCD involves obsessions, compulsions or both. If checking or mental rituals take up time or cause distress, a clinician can help you understand what’s happening. Read the NHS overview of OCD.

Do I have to find out where my standards started?

No. You can begin with a rule you follow now and ask what you expect to happen if you ease up on it. An older memory may give you more to talk about if it comes up.

Explore more articles in the journal