Marcus is thirty-six and has been in Singapore for three years. On Thursday night the argument is about the dishwasher. On Friday it is about his mother’s visit. On Saturday it is about the fact he checked his phone while she was talking. By Sunday they are arguing about how much they argue.

He says she is never happy. She says he never listens. Both are describing the same fifteen minutes from opposite ends.

The people here are composites, not clients. The pattern is the most common one I see in couples abroad, where two people with no family nearby and long working days become each other’s only witness, and every small failure lands with nobody else to absorb it.

The short answer

Couples who argue about everything are having one argument with a hundred subjects. Underneath, one person is asking “are you with me?” and the other is answering “why am I always wrong?” Four moves make it worse: defending, fixing, going quiet and scorekeeping. It stops in the first ninety seconds: notice the heat, name the real subject, ask what she needed, repeat it back without a but, and offer one small thing tonight. Afterwards, repair the door closing, not your position.

Why we argue about everything: a man and a woman stare into an enormous open dishwasher holding one red plate
The subject is the dishwasher. The question is “are you with me, and do I matter to you?”
· · ·

01The dishwasher

The answer she gets, when you explain why the dishwasher was loaded correctly, is no. Not because you said no. Because you answered the subject and walked past the question.

· · ·

02The one argument you keep having

Most couples have a single argument with a hundred subjects. Sue Johnson, whose work on couples underpins much of mine, describes it as a pursue-and-withdraw dance. One partner, often the wife, raises something because she wants contact and does not know how else to get it. The other, often the husband, hears criticism and defends, fixes, or goes quiet. She raises her voice to be heard. He withdraws further to keep the peace. Each is responding to the other’s worst moment and neither is getting what they came for.

Four things which get said in the kitchen, and the question underneath each one. Tap a card to turn it.

“You never listen.”
what is said
I have stopped believing I matter to you.
what is underneath
“Why is it always my fault?”
what is said
I cannot be close to you and be wrong at the same time.
what is underneath
“Fine. Do it your way.”
what is said
I am leaving the room because staying hurts.
what is underneath
“You did it again.”
what is said
I keep asking for you and getting a solution.
what is underneath
Test it

Think of your last three arguments. Strip the subject away. What was she asking for underneath, and what were you protecting? If you find the same two answers three times, you have found your argument.

· · ·

03The four moves which make it worse

The moveWhat it tells her
Defending: “I did load it properly.”The complaint mattered more to you than she did. Being right costs you the evening.
Fixing: three solutions to a hard day.She wanted a witness. You handed her a to-do list and a hint she is not coping.
Going quiet.The door closing in the middle of a sentence. The single move most likely to make her louder.
Scorekeeping: what you earn, what you did last week.The ledger is real and it is irrelevant. Nobody has ever been argued into feeling closer.
· · ·

04The ninety-second way to stop an argument

You will not stop arguments by never disagreeing. You stop them by changing what happens in the first ninety seconds, before either of you is fully in the dance.

Notice the heat. Jaw, chest, the urge to explain. This is the moment. Ten seconds later it is gone.

Say the real subject out loud. “I think we are about to have the dishwasher argument, and I do not think it is about the dishwasher.” Naming the dance interrupts it.

Ask what she needed. “What did you want from me when you said it?” Then wait. Do not fill the gap.

Repeat it back, without a but. “You wanted me to see how much you did today and I walked past it.” No defence, no explanation, no “but I…”.

Offer one thing. Not a plan. One thing, tonight. “Sit down. I will do the kitchen and then tell me about the call with your mum.”

Repeating what she said, accurately, without adding your side, is the one move which has no counter. There is nothing in it to argue with.

Kita Tabachka, relational therapist
Interactive reflection

Which dance are you in?

Six questions for the man who is tired of the same fight. Not a verdict. A mirror.

This cannot see your marriage. If anything here resonates, it is worth exploring with a person, not a page.

Book a free consultation
· · ·

05When you did not manage it: repair after

Repair after an argument: a man and a woman sit close on a bench, he offers a red cup and her hand reaches for it
A repair is short. It is not an apology for your position. It is an apology for the door closing.

You will fail at this. Everyone does. The measure of a marriage is not how few fights it has but how quickly and how well the two people come back afterwards. John Gottman’s research on thousands of couples found repair attempts, not the absence of conflict, were the strongest predictor of couples who stayed together and stayed close.

“I went into defending last night and I did not hear you. Will you tell me again?” Make it the same day where possible, the next morning otherwise, and never in a text.

· · ·

06When the subject is money, family, sex or the move

The subjectThe question underneath
Money“Do I have any say in this life?” especially where one income pays for everything and one person signs for it.
Family“Whose side are you on?” A husband who answers his mother before his wife has answered it without meaning to.
Sex“Do you still want me, or do you want sex?” from one side. “Am I still allowed to want anything?” from the other.
The move abroad“You got a career and I got a flat.” If she followed you, the argument about everything is often the argument about this.

The last one deserves a whole conversation of its own rather than a hundred small ones. The page on expat relationship problems is where to start, and cross-cultural couples therapy covers families in two countries.

· · ·

07When to get help

If you have both tried and the dance restarts within a day, if contempt has crept in on either side, sneering, eye-rolling, mockery, if one of you has stopped bothering to argue, or if the arguments have started to frighten either of you or the children, the pattern has outgrown a technique. Couples therapy for this is practical: we slow one argument down enough to see the dance, and we practise the ninety seconds in a room where nobody has to win.

I am trained in the Gottman approach and work mostly with couples and men abroad, in Dubai, Riyadh, Singapore and London. Couples join from the same sofa or from two countries. Couples online sessions in English cost £100 for 70 minutes. Individual sessions, if you want to work on your side of the dance first, cost £70 for 50 minutes.

Please read this carefully

If there is fear, threats or physical force from either side, this is not an argument pattern and needs a specialist service first. Couples work is never the answer where there is coercion or fear. If you are ever in danger, contact local emergency services.

A man finding the words for an email, with work and relationship worries on his mind.

Weekly written counselling with Kita

When writing feels easier than speaking.

You can enquire about weekly written counselling for your own experience of relationships and life abroad. We agree whether this format is a useful fit before you pay.

Explore written counselling

£50 per week. One personal written reply through Carepatron. Suitability, your weekly reply day and terms agreed before payment.

Kita Tabachka, BACP-registered relational therapist
Written by

Kita Tabachka

I am a BACP-registered relational therapist. I work with individuals and couples, many of them living far from where they began, on relationship anxiety, attachment, intimacy and the strange business of building a self in a new country. The stories here are composites. The patterns are real. My writing is a door into the work, never a substitute for it.

More about my practice
From my shop · Therapy Tools Hub
Tools for anxiety, attachment and steadier love
Affordable, instantly downloadable tools I trust. Tap any cover to explore, or add it straight to your basket.
· · ·

Questions men ask me about arguing

Because you are having one argument with many subjects. Underneath most of them one of you is asking whether you matter to the other, and the other is asking why they are always wrong. Strip the subject away from your last three arguments and you will usually find the same two questions.
Notice the heat in the first ninety seconds, name the real subject out loud, ask what she needed from you, repeat it back without a but, and offer one small thing tonight. Repeating what she said accurately is the one move with no counter.
Frequent arguing is common and not on its own a sign the marriage is failing. What predicts trouble is contempt, one person giving up, and the absence of repair afterwards. Couples who fight and repair well tend to stay close.
No. Withdrawal feels calm from your side and feels like a door closing from hers, and it is the move most likely to make her louder. Stay in the room, say the real subject, and listen before you answer.
Yes, when both people want the dance to stop rather than to win it. The work slows one argument down enough to see the pattern and practises the first ninety seconds where nobody has to be right. Online sessions work for couples in the same home or in two countries.
A pattern described in Sue Johnson’s work: one partner raises things and gets louder to be heard, the other hears criticism and defends, fixes or goes quiet, and each response makes the other worse. Most constant arguing is this cycle wearing different subjects.

Join the conversation

If you have lived this, say so. Your words may be the thing a stranger at midnight needed to read.

Moderated with care. Be kind. This space is for stories, not advice.

No comments yet. Be the first to share what this brought up for you.
A note on this writing

This article is written by Kita Tabachka, MBACP, and is for general education and reflection. It describes patterns seen in clinical work, but it is not therapy, and it is not a substitute for individual advice from a qualified therapist, doctor or other professional who knows your situation.

Reading it cannot diagnose anything or replace your own judgement about what you need. If something here resonates and you would like support, you are welcome to learn more about my practice or book a free consultation. If you are in crisis or immediate danger, please contact local emergency services or an urgent mental health line in your country.